In yet another edict that defies both medicine and mainstream Islamic scholarship, the Taliban regime has ordered surgeons in Afghanistan to stop corneal transplants, the only treatment that can restore sight to people blinded by corneal disease or injury. According to doctors who spoke to The Telegraph, Taliban officials have ruled the procedure impermissible under their reading of Islamic teachings, and hundreds of Afghans every year will now be denied sight-saving surgery.
The order was reportedly delivered verbally, with surgeons told to halt operations and the transplant programme stopped in August. Patients already registered for surgery, including victims of bomb blasts, have simply been turned away.
This is not an isolated decree. In December 2024, the regime imposed a sweeping ban on organ transplants, declaring the transplant of the heart, kidneys and lungs “un-Islamic.” Afghan Islamic scholars questioned that justification at the time, pointing out that leading contemporary jurists allow voluntary donation. The corneal ban extends the same twisted logic to the eyes.
The Taliban’s claim to speak for Shariah collapses under scrutiny. Research on Islamic legal opinions finds that Islamic jurisprudence overwhelmingly supports corneal donation as a permissible and charitable act. Across the Muslim world, from Pakistan to Saudi Arabia and Egypt, corneal transplants are routine. What Kabul calls religion is in fact the regime’s own narrow, self-serving interpretation, imposed on a population that has no voice.
Pakistan has seen this pattern before. Earlier this year, the Pakistan Ulema Council declared the Taliban’s new penal code un-Islamic, saying it contradicts the Quran and Sunnah and offends human dignity. The corneal ban confirms what Pakistani scholars have warned: the Taliban are using the name of Islam to justify cruelty.
The contrast with Pakistan could not be sharper. Through partners such as the Illinois-based Association of Physicians of Pakistani Descent of North America (APPNA), free corneas have been supplied to Pakistan since 2017, restoring sight to 10,000 people. APPNA says the Taliban’s directives have severely disrupted the programme and has urged Kabul to allow the transplants in a country devastated by decades of war.
While Pakistan treats the sick, Kabul punishes them. Those in the region and beyond who keep lecturing Islamabad while legitimising the Taliban must now answer a simple question: what kind of government blinds its own people and calls it faith?
SAT Commentaries, a collection of insightful social media threads on current events and social issues, featuring diverse perspectives from various authors.
SAT Commentary
SAT Commentaries, a collection of insightful social media threads on current events and social issues, featuring diverse perspectives from various authors.
Washington and Tehran may be talking again, or at least writing. The Wall Street Journal reports, citing US officials and people familiar with the matter,
In 2026, Pakistan topped the ranking on the Global Terrorism Index for the first time in the index’s history. Terrorist attacks more than doubled between
Iran’s Foreign Ministry spokesperson Esmaeil Baqaei has taken aim at Washington over the Islamabad Memorandum of Understanding. He claims President Trump admitted he “never believed”
Taliban Turn Out the Lights: Kabul’s Ban on Corneal Transplants Blinds Afghans in the Name of Islam
In yet another edict that defies both medicine and mainstream Islamic scholarship, the Taliban regime has ordered surgeons in Afghanistan to stop corneal transplants, the only treatment that can restore sight to people blinded by corneal disease or injury. According to doctors who spoke to The Telegraph, Taliban officials have ruled the procedure impermissible under their reading of Islamic teachings, and hundreds of Afghans every year will now be denied sight-saving surgery.
The order was reportedly delivered verbally, with surgeons told to halt operations and the transplant programme stopped in August. Patients already registered for surgery, including victims of bomb blasts, have simply been turned away.
This is not an isolated decree. In December 2024, the regime imposed a sweeping ban on organ transplants, declaring the transplant of the heart, kidneys and lungs “un-Islamic.” Afghan Islamic scholars questioned that justification at the time, pointing out that leading contemporary jurists allow voluntary donation. The corneal ban extends the same twisted logic to the eyes.
The Taliban’s claim to speak for Shariah collapses under scrutiny. Research on Islamic legal opinions finds that Islamic jurisprudence overwhelmingly supports corneal donation as a permissible and charitable act. Across the Muslim world, from Pakistan to Saudi Arabia and Egypt, corneal transplants are routine. What Kabul calls religion is in fact the regime’s own narrow, self-serving interpretation, imposed on a population that has no voice.
Pakistan has seen this pattern before. Earlier this year, the Pakistan Ulema Council declared the Taliban’s new penal code un-Islamic, saying it contradicts the Quran and Sunnah and offends human dignity. The corneal ban confirms what Pakistani scholars have warned: the Taliban are using the name of Islam to justify cruelty.
The contrast with Pakistan could not be sharper. Through partners such as the Illinois-based Association of Physicians of Pakistani Descent of North America (APPNA), free corneas have been supplied to Pakistan since 2017, restoring sight to 10,000 people. APPNA says the Taliban’s directives have severely disrupted the programme and has urged Kabul to allow the transplants in a country devastated by decades of war.
While Pakistan treats the sick, Kabul punishes them. Those in the region and beyond who keep lecturing Islamabad while legitimising the Taliban must now answer a simple question: what kind of government blinds its own people and calls it faith?
SAT Commentary
SAT Commentaries, a collection of insightful social media threads on current events and social issues, featuring diverse perspectives from various authors.
SAT Commentary
Recent
Countdown To November 3: Iran Peace Bid, Israel’s Election Deadlock And US Midterm Strike Fears
Washington: President Trump told Axios on 28 October: “We need to finish the job — either through a deal or another way — we will
A Letter Before The Strikes: Vance’s Reported Outreach To Tehran
Washington and Tehran may be talking again, or at least writing. The Wall Street Journal reports, citing US officials and people familiar with the matter,
The West Is Walking Itself Down the Primrose Path
When a discourse closes itself against its best critics, it does not become wiser — it becomes more dangerous. In the autumn of 2015, John
Ownership Before Mandate: Fixing Pakistan’s Peace Education Gap
In 2026, Pakistan topped the ranking on the Global Terrorism Index for the first time in the index’s history. Terrorist attacks more than doubled between
Wrong remarks, wrong order: Iran’s spin on the Islamabad MoU
Iran’s Foreign Ministry spokesperson Esmaeil Baqaei has taken aim at Washington over the Islamabad Memorandum of Understanding. He claims President Trump admitted he “never believed”