Kabul University Show Cannot Hide Hibatullah’s Missing Mandate

In a joint statement, the Islamic Society of Afghanistan and the National Resistance Front of Afghanistan dismissed the Taliban Regime’s latest effort to build a show of legitimacy for Sheikh Hibatullah Akhundzada through Kabul University and a hand-selected group of religious scholars. Their message is clear. Legitimacy comes from the consent of the people, real political participation, justice and accountability. Choreographed endorsements cannot provide it.

The Kabul University event was built to show support for Hibatullah, not to reflect what Afghans want. A room filled with chosen loyalists cannot give anyone a national mandate. What took place was political theatre, staged by a regime that does not have popular backing and knows it.

The way the event was organised says even more. Teaching was halted, students were moved out of university housing, and religious figures were brought in to approve Hibatullah’s decrees. One of Afghanistan’s main centres of learning was turned into a venue for regime propaganda, a political rally dressed up as a scholarly gathering.

Religious authority was also put to political use. Professors were asked whether Hibatullah should be given the title of Sheikh-ul-Islam. Taliban-run media then announced that the title had been approved, without saying who took part or how any vote was held. That was a test of loyalty, not a religious consensus.

Hibatullah’s own words show how he rules. He called on Afghans to love and obey the supreme leader and to follow his decrees without question. Loyalty to one man is not loyalty to Islam, and it is not loyalty to Afghanistan. A leader who demands personal devotion in place of public consent is governing by command, not by mandate.

The regime’s claim to unity is also wearing thin. Sirajuddin Haqqani has openly admitted that he disagrees with Hibatullah’s policies and has warned against glorifying individuals. Criticism voiced in public at that level shows deep divisions behind the regime’s image of discipline. The split between Kandahar and the Haqqanis is no longer hidden.

Outside the Taliban’s ranks, the challenge is getting sharper. Yasin Zia, leader of the Afghanistan Freedom Front, has called for a lawful, inclusive and elected political order. His aim is a real political alternative, not swapping one ruling faction for another. Zia has stressed justice and handing power back to the Afghan people. Taliban offers of posts and positions cannot replace genuine participation, and the resistance has made clear it is not looking for seats at a table the Taliban controls.

The Islamic Society of Afghanistan and the National Resistance Front have set out the same position. They are calling for nationwide elections, equal citizenship, the rule of law and accountability. This is a demand for political reform, not a share of Taliban positions, and it goes directly against the closed, exclusionary structure the regime has built.

At the centre of this is a basic contradiction. The Taliban Regime cannot claim to represent people it shuts out. Women, political movements and large parts of Afghan society are still denied any real role in public life. Rule through force and decrees cannot produce national consensus, however many staged gatherings are held to suggest otherwise.

Religion cannot be used to justify tyranny either. Justice, consultation (shura), accountability and human dignity are core Islamic principles, and they are the principles the Taliban’s style of rule ignores. The duty of scholars is to stand against oppression, not to give religious cover to one group’s grip on power.

Afghanistan’s future belongs to its people, not to Sheikh Hibatullah or his Kandahari Shura. Real legitimacy needs free choice, nationwide elections and equal political participation. No staged gathering at Kabul University can hide the legitimacy crisis at the heart of the Taliban Regime.

SAT Commentaries, a collection of insightful social media threads on current events and social issues, featuring diverse perspectives from various authors.