Journalist Shahid Maitla first tried to blackmail former Prime Minister, Anwar-ul-haw Kakar. When Mr Kakar refused to succumb to his pressure, the former started posting derogatory social media messages on social media platform, X. The journalist was arrested. A flurry of condemnation from journalists’ community leaders followed. In this way the arrest generated a debate about freedom of expression and rights of journalists. The question is, does professional association with media houses give the journalists impunity from consequences of their deliberate actions?
Free press is essential for a stable democratic political system. A journalist must be free to criticize the wrongdoings of any government and any other violation of legal, political and social norms and traditions. But journalists should not be above the law. Publication of unsubstantiated allegations or deliberating damaging someone’s reputation cannot be defended in the name of press freedom. A journalist, just like any other citizen, remains subject to law. There should be a difference between protecting journalism and protecting journalists from accountability.
Pakistan’s legal system has provisions for regulatory and institutional mechanisms for addressing the complaints against journalists and media houses. The problem is these institutions have not developed sufficient power, credibility and effectiveness to regulate the media environment. Weak enforcement of laws results in irresponsible journalism, circulation of sensational and unsubstantiated information. This has become routine in our society.
In case of social media, an effective and meaningful oversight is missing. This is the difference between social media and conventional media like newspapers and TV channels—the former is completely unfettered and without any kind of oversight. Newspapers and electronic channels are supposed to be structured in a way to ensure the presence of oversight and filters through which information passes and gets ready for publication. When regulatory institutions fail to perform their function properly the disputes find their way into courts. Media regulatory institutions and their effectiveness is a must to protect citizens from journalists and media houses. Similarly, if there is strong regulation of laws, the question of high-handedness of the state institutions will not arise.
In Pakistan we have developed a culture where professional organizations display solidarity to claim impunity from law for their members. Journalists are not the only profession indulging in this unethical behavior. We see doctors, lawyers, teachers, businessmen and religious organizations invoking collective solidarity to claim impunity from legal accountability. We must replace this with a culture where collective solidarity doesn’t become collective impunity.
Pakistan needs strong regulatory institutions especially for media and journalists. There is no democracy in the modern world where the media is immune from accountability before law. This rare distinction belongs to Pakistan. And irony is that it is also in our country where the media community accuses the government of displaying high-handed tactics towards the media community.
Your go-to editorial hub for policy perspectives and informed analysis on pressing regional and global issues.




