The Taliban’s supreme leader, Sheikh Hibatullah Akhundzada, has again told his fighters that no one may leave for so-called jihad without his permission. Speaking in Maidan Wardak, he warned that anyone who moves from one place to another without his approval is guilty of disobedience. Such people, he said, are no longer members of the Islamic Emirate, and their claimed affiliations mean nothing. He ordered officials to bring these fighters back, whoever they are.
According to remarks circulated in a Taliban WhatsApp group and shared by Afghan journalist Sami Yousafzai, Hibatullah admitted that he receives many complaints from Maidan Wardak about fighters ignoring orders. In his words, mujahideen there are leaving “on one pretext or another in the name of jihad.” He singled out the province because its people have given many martyrs and suffered greatly.
An Old Promise, Repeated Again
None of this is new. In August 2023, Taliban Defence Minister Mullah Yaqoob told fighters that if they keep fighting after the emir has ordered them to stop, “it is not jihad but rather hostility.” In the same month, Taliban spokesman Zabihullah Mujahid said that under the decree, fighters could be sent abroad only on the leader’s orders. By May 2025, the Taliban had issued this directive to commanders on Pakistan’s western border for the third time: any jihad without the Amir’s decree or the Council of Ulema’s approval counts as fasad, or illegal disorder. Earlier this year, a Taliban district chief in this same province, Maidan Wardak, warned fighters that crossing into Pakistan without authorisation was illegal and religiously forbidden.
So the Taliban have given the same order again and again, and it has made no difference. Cross-border terrorism has not fallen. Dozens of TTP tashkeels (armed units) are still crossing into Pakistan, and a growing share of their fighters are Afghan nationals. Islamabad has publicly identified Afghan nationals as the bombers behind recent suicide attacks on Pakistani soil.
Complicity Or Incapacity, Kabul Must Choose
Hibatullah has now admitted in his own words that fighters are leaving his ranks for “jihad” without permission. That admission leaves the Taliban regime with only two explanations, and neither helps Kabul.
The first is complicity. If the regime can enforce its will on girls’ schools, beards and media across Afghanistan, it is hard to believe it cannot stop armed men from walking across the border. Then the repeated decrees are only for show, issued to deflect Pakistani pressure while the TTP pipeline keeps running. In that case, Pakistan is right to conclude that the Afghan regime is knowingly letting fighters join the TTP.
The second is incapacity. If Hibatullah’s commanders in Wardak are openly ignoring his orders, the Taliban do not control the territory they claim to govern. A regime that cannot stop its own fighters from joining a terrorist war against a neighbour lacks the writ of a functioning state.
The Way Forward
If the Taliban want the world to believe they are not complicit, there is a clear test. A regime that cannot enforce its own decrees must accept help from those who can. Kabul should cooperate fully with Pakistan to dismantle TTP and BLA sanctuaries on Afghan soil. That means sharing intelligence, handing over wanted militants, and allowing verifiable action against training camps and safe houses.
Pakistan has lost thousands of soldiers and civilians to terrorism launched from Afghan territory. It cannot keep accepting decrees that are announced, repeated and then ignored. Hibatullah’s Wardak speech shows that even the Amir admits his orders are not being obeyed. Kabul must now either stop the fighters or let Pakistan help stop them. Doing neither would show the world which side the regime is on.
SAT Commentaries, a collection of insightful social media threads on current events and social issues, featuring diverse perspectives from various authors.
Hibatullah’s Orders Ring Hollow As Afghan Fighters Keep Crossing Into Pakistan
The Taliban’s supreme leader, Sheikh Hibatullah Akhundzada, has again told his fighters that no one may leave for so-called jihad without his permission. Speaking in Maidan Wardak, he warned that anyone who moves from one place to another without his approval is guilty of disobedience. Such people, he said, are no longer members of the Islamic Emirate, and their claimed affiliations mean nothing. He ordered officials to bring these fighters back, whoever they are.
According to remarks circulated in a Taliban WhatsApp group and shared by Afghan journalist Sami Yousafzai, Hibatullah admitted that he receives many complaints from Maidan Wardak about fighters ignoring orders. In his words, mujahideen there are leaving “on one pretext or another in the name of jihad.” He singled out the province because its people have given many martyrs and suffered greatly.
An Old Promise, Repeated Again
None of this is new. In August 2023, Taliban Defence Minister Mullah Yaqoob told fighters that if they keep fighting after the emir has ordered them to stop, “it is not jihad but rather hostility.” In the same month, Taliban spokesman Zabihullah Mujahid said that under the decree, fighters could be sent abroad only on the leader’s orders. By May 2025, the Taliban had issued this directive to commanders on Pakistan’s western border for the third time: any jihad without the Amir’s decree or the Council of Ulema’s approval counts as fasad, or illegal disorder. Earlier this year, a Taliban district chief in this same province, Maidan Wardak, warned fighters that crossing into Pakistan without authorisation was illegal and religiously forbidden.
So the Taliban have given the same order again and again, and it has made no difference. Cross-border terrorism has not fallen. Dozens of TTP tashkeels (armed units) are still crossing into Pakistan, and a growing share of their fighters are Afghan nationals. Islamabad has publicly identified Afghan nationals as the bombers behind recent suicide attacks on Pakistani soil.
Complicity Or Incapacity, Kabul Must Choose
Hibatullah has now admitted in his own words that fighters are leaving his ranks for “jihad” without permission. That admission leaves the Taliban regime with only two explanations, and neither helps Kabul.
The first is complicity. If the regime can enforce its will on girls’ schools, beards and media across Afghanistan, it is hard to believe it cannot stop armed men from walking across the border. Then the repeated decrees are only for show, issued to deflect Pakistani pressure while the TTP pipeline keeps running. In that case, Pakistan is right to conclude that the Afghan regime is knowingly letting fighters join the TTP.
The second is incapacity. If Hibatullah’s commanders in Wardak are openly ignoring his orders, the Taliban do not control the territory they claim to govern. A regime that cannot stop its own fighters from joining a terrorist war against a neighbour lacks the writ of a functioning state.
The Way Forward
If the Taliban want the world to believe they are not complicit, there is a clear test. A regime that cannot enforce its own decrees must accept help from those who can. Kabul should cooperate fully with Pakistan to dismantle TTP and BLA sanctuaries on Afghan soil. That means sharing intelligence, handing over wanted militants, and allowing verifiable action against training camps and safe houses.
Pakistan has lost thousands of soldiers and civilians to terrorism launched from Afghan territory. It cannot keep accepting decrees that are announced, repeated and then ignored. Hibatullah’s Wardak speech shows that even the Amir admits his orders are not being obeyed. Kabul must now either stop the fighters or let Pakistan help stop them. Doing neither would show the world which side the regime is on.
SAT Commentary
SAT Commentaries, a collection of insightful social media threads on current events and social issues, featuring diverse perspectives from various authors.
SAT Commentary
Recent
Hibatullah’s Orders Ring Hollow As Afghan Fighters Keep Crossing Into Pakistan
When the Ballot Box Strikes Back
COP31: Climate Action Needs Fair Finance, Not More Debt
The Untapped Economic Potential of Pakistan–Russia Relations