Perhaps CNN is the only American news channel with substantial viewership in Third World countries like Pakistan and Iran. On November 16, it published a report on its website alleging that American intelligence had detected an Iranian plan to detonate a chemical bomb in Washington D.C with the aim to kill senior officials of the Trump Administration. The report is based on information attributed to an unnamed US intelligence source.
This is a serious and extraordinary allegation, which requires extraordinary journalistic scrutiny. It simply cannot be based on the authority of an anonymous intelligence source.
Secondly, the report doesn’t include publicly available evidence that could have confirmed the allegation. The American media has a responsibility to examine and scrutinize intelligence claims in the light of publicly available evidence like expert opinion, and common sense. The unnamed intelligence source quoted in the report describes alleged contingency planning. The report doesn’t establish that Iranian have made a decision to attack Washington.
We would ask our readers to imagine a world where American cultural and political dominance don’t exist. In such a world Iranian complaint about the American use of lethal military weapons to destroy Iran’s economic infrastructure would receive the same attention and consideration as American dubious allegations about potential attack on Washington.
In such a world, Iranian complaints about destruction of dams, bridges, power generation plants and economic infrastructure would not be reduced to the concept of collateral damage of legitimate military operations.
The question is: can the American media imagine a world from the perspective of victims of American military might? Or is it only trained to project American society as a potential victim of a deadly conspiracy? I think nobody will mind if the American media wants to behave like a nationalistic media as everyone does. But then claims of higher moral ground will not be available to it.
To act morally may be the essence of American liberal political thought. However, you can either profess liberalism as a universally applicable political and social philosophy, or you can continue to apply different standards of morality to the killing of 200 Iranian kids because of an American missile strike and dub the incident as collateral damage. While insinuating an imaginary Iranian plan to use chemical weapons against Washington as violation of international morality.
Use of chemical weapons or any other lethal military weapons against civilian population is a highly condemnable act. But civilian sufferings don’t become less important only because civilians are Iranians and not Americans.
A large part of the American mainstream media applies different standards of scrutiny to America’s military adversaries while treating American military and its excesses with kid gloves.
A news story favorable to American military and security apparatus usually contains quotes from unnamed American officials or intelligence officials. These stories usually project American security concerns as universal security concerns, while the same stories marginalize the security and humanitarian concerns of other societies.
American media has a viewership and readership all around the world. This media cannot continue to enjoy international credibility if it continues to define morality from the perspective of American strategic and military interests.
The civilian lives deserve as much respect in Tehran and Isfahan as they do in Washington. The destruction of human livelihood cannot be justified just because victims are from a country which is a military adversary of the United States. If the American media wants to retain its standing as international media, it must evolve a universal concept of morality, which should not only reflect the fears of American society.
Your go-to editorial hub for policy perspectives and informed analysis on pressing regional and global issues.




