On January 28, 2025, Canada released the Final Report of the Public Inquiry into Foreign Interference (PIFI), bringing to light troubling evidence of foreign influence in the country’s democratic institutions. Led by Justice Marie-Josée Hogue, the inquiry investigated alleged interference by multiple states, including China, Russia, and India, in Canada’s political and electoral processes.
While the report concluded that these foreign efforts did not alter election results, it warned of systematic, long-term attempts to manipulate Canada’s democratic institutions. Among the most striking revelations was India’s involvement in transnational repression and political interference, particularly targeting Sikh activists and pro-Khalistan supporters.
As Western democracies grapple with the challenges posed by foreign interference, India’s growing role in influencing political landscapes abroad has raised critical concerns about democratic sovereignty, national security, and civil liberties.
Political Interference and Transnational Repression
The PIFI Report classified India as a “moderate to high” threat to Canadian democracy—an alarming designation typically applied to states engaged in destabilization strategies. According to the findings, India’s interference operates through both community-level initiatives and state-directed strategies, designed to neutralize opposition voices, reshape public narratives, and advance New Delhi’s geopolitical objectives abroad.
PIFI Report: Key Findings on India’s Influence Operations:
- Community-Level Suppression – Surveillance, coercion, and intimidation targeting Sikh activists, journalists, and community leaders advocating for Khalistan.
- State-Directed Political Lobbying – Using diplomatic pressure, economic leverage, and media influence to sway political actors and public discourse in Canada.
- Espionage and Extraterritorial Targeting – Intelligence-led operations allegedly involved in monitoring, harassing, and even orchestrating threats against dissidents abroad.
These actions, according to the inquiry, go beyond conventional diplomacy and fall into a pattern of transnational repression—a term used to describe state-led efforts to silence dissent outside a country’s borders.
Also See: Inside & Beyond the India-Canada Diplomatic Trouble
Canada: A Key Target of Indian Interference
Canada’s large Sikh diaspora—estimated at over 770,000 people—has made it a focal point of Indian influence operations. The PIFI Report detailed multiple tactics employed by Indian intelligence and diplomatic networks, including:
- Surveillance and Threats – Indian intelligence agencies allegedly tracked Sikh activists and journalists, exerting pressure through diplomatic and non-state actors.
- Political Influence and Media Manipulation – Engaging in covert lobbying efforts and information campaigns to shift public opinion and marginalize voices critical of India’s policies.
- Economic and Diplomatic Coercion – Leveraging trade ties and diplomatic channels to discourage support for Sikh self-determination movements.
- Extrajudicial Operations – Allegations of Indian involvement in the targeted killing of Sikh leader Hardeep Singh Nijjar in British Columbia (June 18, 2023) further intensified scrutiny of New Delhi’s foreign actions.
A Global Pattern: UK and US Also Under Pressure
India’s foreign interference efforts are not limited to Canada. Similar trends have been reported in the UK and the US, where India has used diaspora networks and diplomatic channels to push pro-Modi, Hindutva-driven narratives while pressuring political actors into compliance.
- United Kingdom: UK-based Sikh and Kashmiri activists have reported increased surveillance, diplomatic intimidation, and lobbying efforts aimed at discrediting their movements.
- United States: Reports suggest Indian lobbying groups have actively worked to shape U.S. foreign policy on India’s domestic issues, using economic leverage and strategic alliances to suppress criticism.
The PIFI Report’s findings indicate that India’s actions are part of a broader trend of democratic subversion, where states manipulate political systems abroad to serve their domestic and international interests.
A Growing Threat to Democratic Norms
India’s alleged actions mirror the tactics of authoritarian states traditionally associated with foreign interference, such as Russia and China. The PIFI Report underscores how these efforts pose a serious threat to democratic integrity, prompting urgent questions for global policymakers:
- How should democracies counteract foreign interference without compromising diplomatic relations?
- What legal frameworks can be implemented to deter transnational repression?
- To what extent should diaspora communities be protected from state-led intimidation?
The Need for a Coordinated Response
The revelations from Canada’s PIFI Report highlight the necessity for a unified and strategic response from democratic nations. Proposed countermeasures include:
- Stronger Intelligence Cooperation – Enhancing information-sharing among democracies to monitor and counteract foreign influence operations.
- Diplomatic Consequences – Holding states accountable for interference through diplomatic measures, sanctions, and public condemnations.
- Policy Reforms – Strengthening legislative protections against foreign political manipulation and transnational repression.
- Community Awareness and Protection – Educating diaspora communities about foreign interference tactics and providing legal protections for targeted individuals.
Conclusion
The January 28, 2025, PIFI Report serves as a wake-up call: foreign interference is no longer just a theoretical threat—it is an active and ongoing challenge to democratic governance. While Canada has taken a step toward transparency by publicly addressing these concerns, the global implications of India’s actions require broader international scrutiny and response.
This is not just Canada’s problem—it is a matter of global democratic norms. If left unchecked, such tactics could erode political sovereignty and set a dangerous precedent for state-led repression beyond national borders. As the world watches how Canada responds, other democracies must take decisive steps to safeguard their institutions before similar threats escalate elsewhere.
The Modi Doctrine: PIFI Report’s Stark Warning
On January 28, 2025, Canada released the Final Report of the Public Inquiry into Foreign Interference (PIFI), bringing to light troubling evidence of foreign influence in the country’s democratic institutions. Led by Justice Marie-Josée Hogue, the inquiry investigated alleged interference by multiple states, including China, Russia, and India, in Canada’s political and electoral processes.
While the report concluded that these foreign efforts did not alter election results, it warned of systematic, long-term attempts to manipulate Canada’s democratic institutions. Among the most striking revelations was India’s involvement in transnational repression and political interference, particularly targeting Sikh activists and pro-Khalistan supporters.
As Western democracies grapple with the challenges posed by foreign interference, India’s growing role in influencing political landscapes abroad has raised critical concerns about democratic sovereignty, national security, and civil liberties.
Political Interference and Transnational Repression
The PIFI Report classified India as a “moderate to high” threat to Canadian democracy—an alarming designation typically applied to states engaged in destabilization strategies. According to the findings, India’s interference operates through both community-level initiatives and state-directed strategies, designed to neutralize opposition voices, reshape public narratives, and advance New Delhi’s geopolitical objectives abroad.
PIFI Report: Key Findings on India’s Influence Operations:
These actions, according to the inquiry, go beyond conventional diplomacy and fall into a pattern of transnational repression—a term used to describe state-led efforts to silence dissent outside a country’s borders.
Also See: Inside & Beyond the India-Canada Diplomatic Trouble
Canada: A Key Target of Indian Interference
Canada’s large Sikh diaspora—estimated at over 770,000 people—has made it a focal point of Indian influence operations. The PIFI Report detailed multiple tactics employed by Indian intelligence and diplomatic networks, including:
A Global Pattern: UK and US Also Under Pressure
India’s foreign interference efforts are not limited to Canada. Similar trends have been reported in the UK and the US, where India has used diaspora networks and diplomatic channels to push pro-Modi, Hindutva-driven narratives while pressuring political actors into compliance.
The PIFI Report’s findings indicate that India’s actions are part of a broader trend of democratic subversion, where states manipulate political systems abroad to serve their domestic and international interests.
A Growing Threat to Democratic Norms
India’s alleged actions mirror the tactics of authoritarian states traditionally associated with foreign interference, such as Russia and China. The PIFI Report underscores how these efforts pose a serious threat to democratic integrity, prompting urgent questions for global policymakers:
The Need for a Coordinated Response
The revelations from Canada’s PIFI Report highlight the necessity for a unified and strategic response from democratic nations. Proposed countermeasures include:
Conclusion
The January 28, 2025, PIFI Report serves as a wake-up call: foreign interference is no longer just a theoretical threat—it is an active and ongoing challenge to democratic governance. While Canada has taken a step toward transparency by publicly addressing these concerns, the global implications of India’s actions require broader international scrutiny and response.
This is not just Canada’s problem—it is a matter of global democratic norms. If left unchecked, such tactics could erode political sovereignty and set a dangerous precedent for state-led repression beyond national borders. As the world watches how Canada responds, other democracies must take decisive steps to safeguard their institutions before similar threats escalate elsewhere.
SAT Commentary
SAT Commentary
SAT Commentaries, a collection of insightful social media threads on current events and social issues, featuring diverse perspectives from various authors.
Recent
Afghanistan Beyond the Headlines – Post-2021 Trajectory | SAT Study
Behind the claims of stability lies a fragmented Emirate. SAT traces the patterns linking militancy, governance failures and the pressures driving instability and regional fallout far beyond Kabul’s headlines.
Mirage of Indigenization
The crash of a Tejas fighter at the Dubai Air Show has exposed deep structural flaws in India’s flagship indigenous aircraft program. With two airframes lost in under two years and only a few hundred verifiable flying hours, the incident raises fresh questions about the LCA’s safety, its decades-long delays, and the strategic vulnerability created by India’s dependence on aging fleets. This piece explores how the Dubai crash fits into the broader struggle of a project that was meant to symbolize self-reliance but now risks becoming a cautionary tale.
A Disinformation Partnership: How Indo–Taliban Propaganda Tries to Rewrite Pakistan’s Pain
A deeply humanised analysis uncovering how Afghan intelligence and Indian media coordinate disinformation to deflect attention from ISKP and TTP bases inside Afghanistan. The piece contrasts propaganda with Pakistan’s lived experiences, counterterror gains, and the global data that exposes this narrative manipulation.
The US Report on Pakistan’s May Win
The USCC’s 2025 report delivered a rare moment of clarity in South Asian geopolitics. By openly describing Pakistan’s military success over India, the Commission broke with years of cautious Western language and confirmed a shift many analysts had only hinted at. The report’s wording, and the global reactions that followed, mark a turning point in how the 2025 clash is being understood.
Sharia Absolutism at Home, Realpolitik Abroad
The Taliban govern through a stark duality: rigid Sharia enforcement at home paired with flexible, interest-driven diplomacy abroad. Domestically, religion is used to silence women, suppress dissent, and mask governance failures. Yet the same regime that polices Afghan society with severity adopts a pragmatic tone toward India, Russia, and the TTP. This selective morality reflects political survival rather than theology, with lasting implications for Afghanistan and the wider region.