Sher Mohammad Abbas Stanekzai, a senior Taliban leader with historical ties to India, who criticized the ban imposed by Hibatullah Akhundzada on girls’ education, has fled Afghanistan, traveling to India. Despite a travel ban and the imminent threat of arrest, Stanekzai quietly made his way to India, evading Taliban surveillance. Sources tracking his movement indicate that he then traveled to Dubai, allegedly on a RAW-sponsored trip, possibly seeking guidance and financial support to destabilize the already struggling Taliban government.
Also See: Afghanistan’s Taliban: Stuck in the Past, While the World Moves Forward
A Calculated Escape?
Stanekzai, a former officer cadet at India’s Military Academy in Dehradun (1982-1984), has long maintained a favorable stance toward New Delhi. His sudden departure follows an escalating power struggle within the Taliban, where Supreme Leader Hibatullah Akhundzada had reportedly ordered his arrest for opposing key decrees, particularly the controversial ban on women’s education.
The immediate trigger appeared to be Stanekzai’s remarks on January 18 at a madrasa graduation ceremony in Khost Province, where he openly criticized the Taliban’s policy of denying education to girls. He condemned the ongoing ban, stating: “Today, out of a population of 40 million, we are committing injustice against 20 million people.”
Since the Taliban’s return to power in August 2021, girls above grade six have been banned from attending school indefinitely. Stanekzai further lashed out at the policy, declaring:
“Will we not be gathered in the same way on the Day of Judgment? … We have deprived them of all their rights; they have no inheritance rights, no share in determining their husband’s rights, they are sacrificed in forced marriages, they are not allowed to study, they cannot go to mosques, the doors of universities and schools are closed to them, and they are not allowed in religious schools either.”
Stanekzai, in a direct challenge to the Taliban’s hardline stance, asserted that the ban was “not in accordance with Sharia”, as reported by Tolo News. He urged the Taliban leadership to “open the doors of education,” emphasizing that there was no religious justification for such restrictions.
“There is no acceptable excuse for this, and there will never be. In the time of the Prophet Muhammad (PBUH), the doors of knowledge were open to both men and women.”
Meanwhile, Deputy Prime Minister for Economic Affairs Mullah Abdul Ghani Baradar, who has also been at odds with the Kandahar-based leadership, emphasized the importance of modern scientific education alongside religious studies:
“Now is the era of technology; strive to become familiar with modern education and the needs of the present time so that you can truly serve your religion and nation.”
Even Acting Minister for Energy and Water Abdul Latif Mansoor stressed unity within the Taliban ranks, stating:
“Dear elders, maintain your unity; our success lies in unity and solidarity. The unity of ethnic groups, social classes, and these great scholars who have graduated is the key to our success.”
Stanakzai’s Post-Escape Audio Mesaage
Notably, as Abbas Stanekzai is currently in India, a recently surfaced audio clip has revealed his views on leadership within the Taliban. The Deputy Foreign Minister stressed that while it is important to follow the guidance of leaders, they should not be elevated to the status of divine figures, equating them with God or the Prophet. He emphasized that obedience to a leader is warranted only when they are on the right path, and if they stray, their orders should be disregarded. Stanekzai further reminded his audience that leaders are human, and many have come and gone in Afghanistan’s history. He argued that if a leader’s orders are harmful to the country, they should not be followed. However, he made it clear that if a leader calls for the defense of the country against Pakistan or for safeguarding the borders, obedience becomes essential. This statement comes after Stanekzai’s vocal criticism of the Taliban’s Supreme Leader, Hibatullah Akhundzada, over the girls’ education ban, which ultimately led to his departure from Afghanistan.
Internal Taliban Rift Deepens
With Stanekzai’s departure, the divisions within the Taliban have come into sharper focus:
- Sources tracking his movement indicate that Stanekzai’s UAE stay was a cover, and he quietly traveled to India for undisclosed meetings.
- Taliban insiders claim his visit aims to secure financial and strategic backing to counterbalance Akhundzada’s growing crackdown on dissenters.
- His escape follows a deepening rift within the Taliban, with leaders like Mullah Baradar, Sirajuddin Haqqani, and Mawlawi Yaqoob reportedly lobbying for his release.
What’s Next?
If confirmed, the visit of Abbas Stanekzai to India signals a significant shift in regional geopolitics. His outreach to New Delhi—whether for support, asylum, or political maneuvering—could exacerbate the Taliban’s internal fractures at a time when the regime faces economic collapse and diplomatic isolation.
For now, both Kabul and New Delhi remain silent. However, if reports of his India visit hold true, it could mark a major turning point in Afghanistan’s post-Taliban power dynamics.
SAT Commentaries’ are social media threads by various authors, reproduced here for website use. Views are their own.
The Quiet Escape of Abbas Stanekzai to India After Criticizing AIG’s Girls Education Ban
Sher Mohammad Abbas Stanekzai, a senior Taliban leader with historical ties to India, who criticized the ban imposed by Hibatullah Akhundzada on girls’ education, has fled Afghanistan, traveling to India. Despite a travel ban and the imminent threat of arrest, Stanekzai quietly made his way to India, evading Taliban surveillance. Sources tracking his movement indicate that he then traveled to Dubai, allegedly on a RAW-sponsored trip, possibly seeking guidance and financial support to destabilize the already struggling Taliban government.
Also See: Afghanistan’s Taliban: Stuck in the Past, While the World Moves Forward
A Calculated Escape?
Stanekzai, a former officer cadet at India’s Military Academy in Dehradun (1982-1984), has long maintained a favorable stance toward New Delhi. His sudden departure follows an escalating power struggle within the Taliban, where Supreme Leader Hibatullah Akhundzada had reportedly ordered his arrest for opposing key decrees, particularly the controversial ban on women’s education.
The immediate trigger appeared to be Stanekzai’s remarks on January 18 at a madrasa graduation ceremony in Khost Province, where he openly criticized the Taliban’s policy of denying education to girls. He condemned the ongoing ban, stating: “Today, out of a population of 40 million, we are committing injustice against 20 million people.”
Since the Taliban’s return to power in August 2021, girls above grade six have been banned from attending school indefinitely. Stanekzai further lashed out at the policy, declaring:
“Will we not be gathered in the same way on the Day of Judgment? … We have deprived them of all their rights; they have no inheritance rights, no share in determining their husband’s rights, they are sacrificed in forced marriages, they are not allowed to study, they cannot go to mosques, the doors of universities and schools are closed to them, and they are not allowed in religious schools either.”
Stanekzai, in a direct challenge to the Taliban’s hardline stance, asserted that the ban was “not in accordance with Sharia”, as reported by Tolo News. He urged the Taliban leadership to “open the doors of education,” emphasizing that there was no religious justification for such restrictions.
“There is no acceptable excuse for this, and there will never be. In the time of the Prophet Muhammad (PBUH), the doors of knowledge were open to both men and women.”
Meanwhile, Deputy Prime Minister for Economic Affairs Mullah Abdul Ghani Baradar, who has also been at odds with the Kandahar-based leadership, emphasized the importance of modern scientific education alongside religious studies:
“Now is the era of technology; strive to become familiar with modern education and the needs of the present time so that you can truly serve your religion and nation.”
Even Acting Minister for Energy and Water Abdul Latif Mansoor stressed unity within the Taliban ranks, stating:
“Dear elders, maintain your unity; our success lies in unity and solidarity. The unity of ethnic groups, social classes, and these great scholars who have graduated is the key to our success.”
Stanakzai’s Post-Escape Audio Mesaage
Notably, as Abbas Stanekzai is currently in India, a recently surfaced audio clip has revealed his views on leadership within the Taliban. The Deputy Foreign Minister stressed that while it is important to follow the guidance of leaders, they should not be elevated to the status of divine figures, equating them with God or the Prophet. He emphasized that obedience to a leader is warranted only when they are on the right path, and if they stray, their orders should be disregarded. Stanekzai further reminded his audience that leaders are human, and many have come and gone in Afghanistan’s history. He argued that if a leader’s orders are harmful to the country, they should not be followed. However, he made it clear that if a leader calls for the defense of the country against Pakistan or for safeguarding the borders, obedience becomes essential. This statement comes after Stanekzai’s vocal criticism of the Taliban’s Supreme Leader, Hibatullah Akhundzada, over the girls’ education ban, which ultimately led to his departure from Afghanistan.
Internal Taliban Rift Deepens
With Stanekzai’s departure, the divisions within the Taliban have come into sharper focus:
What’s Next?
If confirmed, the visit of Abbas Stanekzai to India signals a significant shift in regional geopolitics. His outreach to New Delhi—whether for support, asylum, or political maneuvering—could exacerbate the Taliban’s internal fractures at a time when the regime faces economic collapse and diplomatic isolation.
For now, both Kabul and New Delhi remain silent. However, if reports of his India visit hold true, it could mark a major turning point in Afghanistan’s post-Taliban power dynamics.
SAT Commentaries’ are social media threads by various authors, reproduced here for website use. Views are their own.
SAT Commentary
SAT Commentary
SAT Commentaries, a collection of insightful social media threads on current events and social issues, featuring diverse perspectives from various authors.
Recent
The End of Liberal Internationalism
The 2025 U.S. National Security Strategy marks a decisive break from the post-1945 liberal order, replacing globalism and multilateralism with a neo-Westphalian focus on sovereign nation-states, fortified borders, and exclusionary spheres of influence. It signals America’s retreat from global leadership and the return of great-power rivalry.
Anonymous Sources, Big Claims, Thin Ground
A recent Drop Site News report claims a covert UK–Pakistan exchange of convicted sex offenders for political dissidents. But a closer look shows the story rests on hearsay, anonymous insiders, and a narrative shaped more by partisan loyalties than evidence. From misrepresenting legally declared propagandists as persecuted critics to ignoring the legal impossibility of such a swap, this report illustrates how modern journalism can slip into activism. When sensational claims outrun facts and legality, credibility collapses, and so does the line between holding power accountable and manufacturing a story.
Zabihullah Mujahid’s Bizarre Statement on TTP: A Lesson in Hypocrisy and Evasion
Zabihullah Mujahid’s recent statement dismissing the TTP as Pakistan’s “internal issue” and claiming Pashto lacks the word “terrorist” is a glaring act of evasion. By downplaying a UN-listed militant group hosted on Afghan soil, the Taliban spokesperson attempts to deflect responsibility, despite overwhelming evidence of TTP sanctuaries, leadership, and operations in Afghanistan. His remarks reveal not linguistic nuance, but calculated hypocrisy and political convenience.
Beyond the Rhetoric: What Muttaqi’s Address Reveals About Afghan Policy
Interim Foreign Minister Amir Khan Muttaqi’s recent address sought to reframe Afghanistan’s strained ties with Pakistan through a narrative of victimhood and denial. From dismissing cross-border militancy to overstating economic resilience, his claims contradict on-ground realities and historical patterns. A closer examination reveals strategic deflection rather than accountability, with serious implications for regional peace and security.
We Want Deliverance
Political mobilization in South Asia is not rooted in policy or institutions but in a profound yearning for deliverance. From Modi’s civilizational aura in India to Imran Khan’s revolutionary moral narrative in Pakistan, voters seek not managers of the state but messianic figures who promise total transformation. This “Messiah Complex” fuels a cycle of charismatic rise, institutional erosion, and eventual democratic breakdown, a pattern embedded in the region’s political psychology and historical imagination.