Zalmay Khalilzad’s recent tweets portray Pakistan as collapsing, criticizing counterterrorism operations while ignoring the real drivers of instability in Balochistan: foreign-backed terrorism, criminal networks, and the civilian and security force toll. By conflating state action with militancy, he misrepresents ground realities and obscures the failures of his own Afghan diplomacy. This commentary exposes the gap between his rhetoric and Pakistan’s efforts to maintain law, order, and development under complex security challenges.
Punjab Farmers Begin Fast-Unto-Death Amid Growing Tensions
When the hands that feed the nation are forced to fast, the irony is hard to miss.
As the farmers’ protest in Punjab intensifies, 111 farmers have pledged to begin a fast-unto-death starting January 15, 2025. Punjab farmers have warned that their fast-unto-death is a last-ditch effort to safeguard their livelihoods and bring attention to their plight. Dressed in black clothes, they’re making a stand against the Centre’s inaction on their demands. This marks a critical moment in their ongoing struggle for justice, as Punjab’s Sikh farmers—hailed as the backbone of India’s agricultural economy—take extreme measures to make their voices heard.
The farmers are protesting not only for their rights but also in solidarity with farmer leader Jagjit Singh Dallewal, who has now entered the 51st day of his own hunger strike. Dallewal’s health is rapidly deteriorating. Moreover, reports indicate multi-organ failure and an inability to even drink water. This highlights the deepening crisis.
Also See: Hindutva: India’s Dangerous Export to the World
A Struggle Against Oppression
In a direct response to the growing unrest, the Haryana police have imposed Section 163 of the BNSS in the area, signaling their commitment to preventing any escalation. Despite these efforts, farmer leaders are unwavering, preparing to hold their ground even if it means facing force from the authorities.
A democracy weaponizes its machinery against Sikh farmers—the lifeline of India’s economy. Forced into hunger strikes in black clothes, their peaceful pleas are met with BJP’s Hindutva-driven oppression. Punjab’s Sikh farmers, the nation’s food providers, face betrayal and police brutality. Ignored by a Hindutva-dominated BJP, their demands turn into a struggle for survival.
The ongoing standoff raises uncomfortable questions about the role of the state in suppressing peaceful protest. Sikh farmers in black clothes symbolize defiance against BJP tyranny. Hindutva policies aim to erase Punjab’s spirit, reducing Sikhs to second-class citizens. Modi’s India is a democracy in name, dictatorship in action. Will global powers let Punjab bleed?
The situation is dire. As the government and protestors remain at an impasse, the larger question looms: Will this struggle for justice gain the attention it deserves? Or will political agendas continue to drown out Punjab’s farmers and their pleas?
Sourced from The New Indian Express
SAT Commentary
SAT Commentary
SAT Commentaries, a collection of insightful social media threads on current events and social issues, featuring diverse perspectives from various authors.
Recent
US Backs Pakistan as Violence Escalates in Balochistan
US support for Pakistan following Balochistan violence reframes the conflict as a global counter-terrorism challenge, not a separatist struggle.
The Journey of a WWI Memorial in Islamabad
For years, the World War I memorial near Rehara village stood quietly above the surrounding land, a small but enduring reminder of local soldiers who
Zalmay Khalilzad’s Distortion of Pakistan’s Security Realities
Zalmay Khalilzad’s recent tweets portray Pakistan as collapsing, criticizing counterterrorism operations while ignoring the real drivers of instability in Balochistan: foreign-backed terrorism, criminal networks, and the civilian and security force toll. By conflating state action with militancy, he misrepresents ground realities and obscures the failures of his own Afghan diplomacy. This commentary exposes the gap between his rhetoric and Pakistan’s efforts to maintain law, order, and development under complex security challenges.
The Indo-Israel Nexus and Proxy Insurgency: Challenges to Pakistan’s Stability in Balochistan
Israel and India’s active support for Baloch militias confirms Pakistan’s long-standing concerns about foreign interference. Through proxy insurgency and narrative campaigns, external actors seek to destabilize Balochistan, undermine Pakistan’s internal security, and disrupt regional connectivity.
Balochistan’s Security Challenges, Criminal Networks, and Ground Realities
Balochistan’s security challenge is not rooted in deprivation alone but in a long-entrenched nexus of militant outfits, criminal mafias, and foreign-sponsored narrative manipulation. The failure of “Operation Herof II” underscores the disconnect between militant propaganda and ground realities.