Liberty, equality, fraternity, or death; – the last, much the easiest to bestow, O Guillotine!
-Charles Dickens, A Tale of Two Cities
The French slogan of “liberty, equality, and fraternity” has been adopted by many nations as an ideal. B.R. Ambedkar, the Chairman of the Drafting Committee of the Constitution of India, included these words in the Preamble to the Constitution of India, in the year 1950.
Even then, the tale of the illegal occupation of Kashmir that began on October 27th, 1947 continues even today as the unilateral unconstitutional act of August 5th, 2019 by New Delhi to abrogate the special status of the Muslim Majority State is being exploited by the Indian Government for a systematic demographic change in Kashmir.
The recent three-day Kashmir visit of Amit Shah to connect with the local extending a hand of “friendship” to the youth is significant as it came at a time when violence caused 38 killings in 20 days of this month – including 11 civilians, 17 rebels and 10 security personnel on one hand, and on the other, the Kashmiri students were booked under terror charges for supporting Pakistan’s Cricket Team.
After August 5th, 2019, this is Amit Shah’s first ever visit to Kashmir. Here, it is notable that Amit Shah has been the one who introduced the bill to abrogate Article 370 in the Indian Parliament two years ago; the very law that ensured the exclusive citizenship rights to the permanent Kashmiri residents barring the outsiders from buying or selling permanent settlements.
With the emergent themes of geoeconomics in the region, Kashmir being the nuclear flashpoint between Pakistan and India has become central to the regional equation of power. Geoeconomics, a term, initially introduced in the post-Cold War context by a United States strategic scholar Edward Luttwak in 1990, being a form of statecraft has now been employed as an “admixture of the logic of war with the methods of commerce”. This can be considered in terms of Amit Shah’s recent visit to Kashmir as reportedly not only the Indian Government is deploying 6000-acre existing land bank to attract investors, Sajjan Jindal’s JSW Steel has also announced a Rs 150 Crore project at Lassipora, Pulwama. In addition, on October 18th, 2021 an agreement for investment in infrastructure has also been signed between Dubai and the Indian Government.
Moreover, Pakistan’s foreign policy shift toward geoeconomic trends earlier in 2021 can also be viewed in terms of the emergent threat matrix in the region centralizing economic security. Coupled with China’s Belt and Road Initiative, Pakistan’s geoeconomics vision centers on regional connectivity and the collective pursuit for sustainable development. In order to encourage the regional environment for peace and stability minimizing the role of Indian state-sponsored proxies waging war on Pakistan via western borders, Pakistan during the Islamabad Security Dialogue has proposed a conditionalized regional trade facilitation for India – based on the peaceful conflict resolution of Kashmir.
The reason that Kashmir is a disputed territory, the Modi Government selling the narrative of ‘Kashmir and Article 370 abrogation’ as an ‘internal matter’, securitizing development for a demographic change is demonstrative of RSS ideology for ‘United India’ in practice.
This can be further ascertained in view of the appointment of Manoj Sinha as the Lieutenant Governor of Jammu and Kashmir; a seasoned politician from Utter Pradesh, a close acquaintance of Modi’s and a strong proponent of Hinduization values. In parallel, the Modi Government has also launched an economic snapshot and vision statement 2030; a framework to convert a demographic majority into a political minority as the reliance of this economic outlay in Jammu and Kashmir is expected to be on the Hindu-migrant businesses.
Considering the recent developments, it can be observed that in the past two years, the spirit of freedom and the right to self determination in Kashmir has only been revitalized.
October 27th, 1947 has been in violation of the Independence Act and the Partition Plan of 1947. Also, New Delhi has been violating the Human Rights conventions since then. Today, Kashmir has become the litmus test for the international rule-based world order established by the United Nations. The constant violation of international norms must come to an end as Kashmiri lives matter!
Kashmir – The Geoeconomic Trends
The French slogan of “liberty, equality, and fraternity” has been adopted by many nations as an ideal. B.R. Ambedkar, the Chairman of the Drafting Committee of the Constitution of India, included these words in the Preamble to the Constitution of India, in the year 1950.
Even then, the tale of the illegal occupation of Kashmir that began on October 27th, 1947 continues even today as the unilateral unconstitutional act of August 5th, 2019 by New Delhi to abrogate the special status of the Muslim Majority State is being exploited by the Indian Government for a systematic demographic change in Kashmir.
The recent three-day Kashmir visit of Amit Shah to connect with the local extending a hand of “friendship” to the youth is significant as it came at a time when violence caused 38 killings in 20 days of this month – including 11 civilians, 17 rebels and 10 security personnel on one hand, and on the other, the Kashmiri students were booked under terror charges for supporting Pakistan’s Cricket Team.
With the emergent themes of geoeconomics in the region, Kashmir being the nuclear flashpoint between Pakistan and India has become central to the regional equation of power. Geoeconomics, a term, initially introduced in the post-Cold War context by a United States strategic scholar Edward Luttwak in 1990, being a form of statecraft has now been employed as an “admixture of the logic of war with the methods of commerce”. This can be considered in terms of Amit Shah’s recent visit to Kashmir as reportedly not only the Indian Government is deploying 6000-acre existing land bank to attract investors, Sajjan Jindal’s JSW Steel has also announced a Rs 150 Crore project at Lassipora, Pulwama. In addition, on October 18th, 2021 an agreement for investment in infrastructure has also been signed between Dubai and the Indian Government.
Moreover, Pakistan’s foreign policy shift toward geoeconomic trends earlier in 2021 can also be viewed in terms of the emergent threat matrix in the region centralizing economic security. Coupled with China’s Belt and Road Initiative, Pakistan’s geoeconomics vision centers on regional connectivity and the collective pursuit for sustainable development. In order to encourage the regional environment for peace and stability minimizing the role of Indian state-sponsored proxies waging war on Pakistan via western borders, Pakistan during the Islamabad Security Dialogue has proposed a conditionalized regional trade facilitation for India – based on the peaceful conflict resolution of Kashmir.
This can be further ascertained in view of the appointment of Manoj Sinha as the Lieutenant Governor of Jammu and Kashmir; a seasoned politician from Utter Pradesh, a close acquaintance of Modi’s and a strong proponent of Hinduization values. In parallel, the Modi Government has also launched an economic snapshot and vision statement 2030; a framework to convert a demographic majority into a political minority as the reliance of this economic outlay in Jammu and Kashmir is expected to be on the Hindu-migrant businesses.
Considering the recent developments, it can be observed that in the past two years, the spirit of freedom and the right to self determination in Kashmir has only been revitalized.
October 27th, 1947 has been in violation of the Independence Act and the Partition Plan of 1947. Also, New Delhi has been violating the Human Rights conventions since then. Today, Kashmir has become the litmus test for the international rule-based world order established by the United Nations. The constant violation of international norms must come to an end as Kashmiri lives matter!
SAT Editorial Desk
SAT Editorial Desk
Your go-to editorial hub for policy perspectives and informed analysis on pressing regional and global issues.
Recent
When Insurgents Rule: The Taliban’s Crisis of Governance
The Taliban’s confrontation with Pakistan reveals a deeper failure at the heart of their rule: an insurgent movement incapable of governing the state it conquered. Bound by rigid ideology and fractured by internal rivalries, the Taliban have turned their military victory into a political and economic collapse, exposing the limits of ruling through insurgent logic.
The Great Unknotting: America’s Tech Break with China, and the Return of the American System
As the U.S. unwinds decades of technological interdependence with China, a new industrial and strategic order is emerging. Through selective decoupling, focused on chips, AI, and critical supply chains, Washington aims to restore domestic manufacturing, secure data sovereignty, and revive the Hamiltonian vision of national self-reliance. This is not isolationism but a recalibration of globalization on America’s terms.
Inside the Istanbul Talks: How Taliban Factionalism Killed a Peace Deal
The collapse of the Turkiye-hosted talks to address the TTP threat was not a diplomatic failure but a calculated act of sabotage from within the Taliban regime. Deep factional divides—between Kandahar, Kabul, and Khost blocs—turned mediation into chaos, as Kabul’s power players sought to use the TTP issue as leverage for U.S. re-engagement and financial relief. The episode exposed a regime too fractured and self-interested to act against terrorism or uphold sovereignty.
The Indo-Afghan Arc: Rewriting Pakistan’s Strategic Geography
The deepening India-Afghanistan engagement marks a new strategic era in South Asia. Beneath the façade of humanitarian cooperation lies a calculated effort to constrict Pakistan’s strategic space, from intelligence leverage and soft power projection to potential encirclement on both eastern and western fronts. Drawing from the insights of Iqbal and Khushhal Khan Khattak, this analysis argues that Pakistan must reclaim its strategic selfhood, strengthen regional diplomacy, and transform its western border from a vulnerability into a vision of regional connectivity and stability.
Legitimacy, Agency, and the Illusion of Mediation
The recent talks in Turkey, attended by Afghan representatives, exposed the delicate politics of legitimacy and agency in Pakistan-Afghanistan relations. By rejecting the Taliban’s proposal to include the TTP, Pakistan safeguarded its sovereignty and avoided legitimizing a militant group as a political actor, preserving its authority and strategic narrative.